I started out liking this book that is about a teenage girl named Ivy who is pregnant and whose parents want to send her away to have the baby and put it up for adoption. The father wants nothing to do with her, and Ivy decides she wants to keep the baby, so she sneaks out at night and meets up with a young woman who is going to Blackwell, a town in western Massachusetts, where a group called the Community believes in love and acceptance. Both girls go there and find out that the handsome and charismatic man running the place, Joel, has a lot of rules, including: no acts of wickedness, no antisocial behavior, no contact with original family, no contact with the outside world, no reading, no attending public schools, no disloyalty, no personal possessions, and no terminating pregnancies. Joel becomes immediately enchanted with Ivy and asks her to marry him, and they do after Mia's birth.
Ivy realizes that she doesn't want to live there anymore, but Joel threatens Mia if she tries to leave. At first, Ivy has little contact with Mia because children belong to the Community, not to individuals, and a woman who cares for the children hates Ivy for taking away Joel and won't let Ivy see her daughter. As time passes and Mia becomes a teen, she and Ivy grow close, and Ivy secretly introduces her to the library. Soon, Mia is sneaking books from the library to read in the barn on an apple farm the Community owns. If you break the rules, you could have your head shaved, be given a letter placard announcing your crime, or a letter burned into your skin.
After Ivy dies, Mia escapes the Community, but finds she cannot escape Joel, who easily finds her. Then the novel takes a sharp left turn into the forest when Mia goes back in time to be with Nathaniel Hawthorne. His book, The Scarlet Letter, saved Mia's life. Ivy's story is a retelling of Hester and Pearl. I feel the book really went off the rails with this diversion to Hawthorne. Up until then, the book is really good. I have really loved some of Hoffman's books, including The Witches of Cambridge, which I reviewed earlier this month. Her writing is magical and beautiful poetry that flows off the page. All her books are worth reading because of her writing. I don't know whether to recommend this book, but I suppose if you read it you will know that it goes a little wonky in the middle.
Quotes
She loved Thoreau for his rebellious thoughts, and the Brontës for their dark and tragic tales of love, and Toni Morrison, whose novels made her cry and feel as if she didn't know the first thing about life.
Alice Hoffman (The Invisible Hour, p.5)
Magic is a made-up concept that gives you the idea that you can control something you have no control over.
Alice Hoffman (The Invisible Hour, p.45)
In a place where books were banned, there could be no personal freedom, no hopes, and no dreams for the future.
Alice Hoffman (The Invisible Hour, p.46)
The worst thing that can happen often happens in silence. It is not the explosion, but the aftermath, when you see through smoke and ash, and you know how much you have lost.
Alice Hoffman (The Invisible Hour, p.68)
-You shouldn't trust me. You don't even know me.
-I know what you like to read. That's good enough for me.
Alice Hoffman (The Invisible Hour, p.76)
Real life is unbelievable. Souls are snatched from us, flesh and blood turn to dust, people you love betray you, men go to war over nothing. It's all preposterous. That's why we have novels. To make sense of things.
Alice Hoffman (The Invisible Hour, p.118)
There was no way for him to explain that a person didn't choose being a writer; writing chose you.
Alice Hoffman (The Invisible Hour, p. 138)
He believed it was possible to see inside a person's soul once you knew which books mattered to them.
Alice Hoffman (The Invisible Hour, p.146)
She remembered that you could never look back, because if you did, you would understand just how much you were about to lose.
Alice Hoffman (The Invisible Hour, p.171)
Love was cruel and unpredictable, and yet he wanted it more than words, more than anything.
Alice Hoffman (The Invisible Hour, p.190)
Mia now understood that Joel was well aware that once a girl walked into a library, she could never be controlled again.
Alice Hoffman (The Invisible Hour, p.226)
Life can be long or short, it is impossible to know, but every once in a while an entire life is spent in one night, the night when the windows are open and you can hear the last of the crickets' call, when there is a chill in the air and the stars are bright, when nothing else matters, when a single kiss lasts longer than a lifetime, when you do not think about the future or the past, or whether or not you are walking through a dream rather than the real world, when everythihg you have always wanted and everything you are fated to mourn forever are tied together with black thread and then sewn with your own hand, when in the morning, as you wake and see the mountain in the distance, you will understand that whether or not you've made a mistake, whether or not you will lose all that you have, this is what it means to be human.
Alice Hoffman (The Invisible Hour, p.228)